fatnews.com

Discussion Forums
NEW!

Discussion Forums

Recent Forum Topics
NEW!

Recent Forum Topics
We welcome your comments, experience, expertise and insight on various topics about weight loss in these discussion forums.

STORE

The Store

SEARCH THIS SITE


Advanced Search

SEARCH THE WEB

Google

CONTACT US

  • Contact Us
  • Submit your suggestions to improve this site
  • Submit an article you would like reviewed
  • Suggest a drug, nutrient or diet you would like reviewed
  • TABLES

    BMI Table for adults
    BMI Table defining childhood obesity
    Glycemic Index Tables

    MEMBERS

    Login
    Register

    MAILING LIST

    CATEGORIES

    (Tip: To find articles about a particular subject, either search for a particular word, click "Category View" above, or select the category you are interested in from the list below.)
    5-HTP (5-Hydroxytryptophan)
    Abilify (aripiprazole)
    Acarbose (Precose)
    Accountability
    ACE Inhibitor
    Acetyl-L-Carnitine
    Acomplia (rimonabant)
    Actonel (risedronate)
    Actos (pioglitazone)
    Adherence (compliance) to treatment
    Adiponectin
    Aging
    AIDS
    Air Conditioning
    Alcohol
    Alcoholism
    Alii (orlistat) - (also see Xenical)
    All-you-can-eat
    Allergies, Food and Brain
    Almonds
    Alpha Lipoic Acid
    Aluminum
    Alzhemier's Disease
    Amantadine (Symmetrel)
    Ambien (zolpidem)
    Amino Acids
    Amitriptyline (See Elavil)
    Amphetamines
    Amylase inhibitors (See Starch Blockers)
    Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS)
    Anafranil (clomipramine)
    Angina (chest pain)
    Animal-based diet
    Antibiotics
    Antidepressants
    Antihistamines
    Antipsychotic drugs
    Anxiety
    Arginine
    Arthritis
    Articles by others
    Artificial sweetners (general)
    Aspartic Acid
    Aspirin
    Asthma
    Attention Deficit Hyperactive Disorder -- ADHD
    Autism
    Avandia (rosiglitazone)
    Axokine
    Bariatric Surgery (See Weight Loss Surgery)
    Behavioral Therapy, Cognitive
    Belviq (lorcaserin hydrochloride)
    Benefits of weight loss
    Benzodiazepines
    Beta Blockers
    Binge Eating
    Bioidentical hormones
    Birth Control Pills
    Blacks
    Blood Donation
    Blood Pressure
    Blood Pressure Drugs
    Blood Pressure Drugs INCREASED Death in Older women
    Blood sugar
    BMI not perfect
    BMI Table
    BMI, Healthiest (Healthiest BMI)
    Body Composition
    Bone Fractures
    Bone mass
    Book - Blue Zones
    Book - Cholesterol Myths (by Uffe Ravnskov, MD, PhD)
    Book - Deadly Medicines and Organised Crime (by Prof. Peter Gøtzsche, MD)
    Book - Deadly Psychiatry and Organised Denial (by Prof. Peter Gøtzsche, MD)
    Book - Good Calories, Bad Calories (by Gary Taubes)
    Book - Malignant Medical Myths
    Book - Our Daily Meds
    Book - The Black Swan
    Book - The Plant Paradox (by Steven Gundry, MD)
    Book - Why We Get Fat (by Gary Taubes)
    Book: The Three Best Ways to Lose Weight
    Brain Allergies (See Allergies, Food and Brain)
    Breakfast
    Breast-feeding
    Broda Barnes, MD, PhD (thyroid expert)
    Bromocriptine (Ergoset)
    Bulimia
    Bupropion (See Wellbutrin)
    Byetta (exenatide)
    C-reactive protein
    Caffeine
    Calcium
    Calcium Channel Blockers
    Calorie content of food
    Calorie Density of Food
    Calorie Intake
    Calorie intake, Underreporting
    Calorie Restriction
    Cancer
    Cancer screening (Does it do any good?)
    Cancer treatments
    Cancer, Bladder
    Cancer, Bowel
    Cancer, Brain
    Cancer, Breast
    Cancer, Cervical
    Cancer, Colorectal
    Cancer, Endometrial
    Cancer, Gallbadder
    Cancer, Hodgkin's Lymphoma
    Cancer, Kidney
    Cancer, Leukemia
    Cancer, Liver
    Cancer, Lung
    Cancer, Multiple Myeloma
    Cancer, Non-Hodgkin's Lymphoma
    Cancer, Oesophageal
    Cancer, Oesophageal (adenocarcinoma)
    Cancer, others
    Cancer, Ovarian
    Cancer, Pancreatic
    Cancer, Prostate
    Cancer, Stomach (gastric cardia)
    Cannabis (marijuana)
    Caralluma fimbriata
    Carbohydrates
    Carnitine, L- (L-carnitine)
    Carpal tunnel syndrome
    Celexa (citalorpam)
    Cell Phones
    Cereal
    Chelation Therapy, EDTA
    Chemtrails
    Chewing
    Childhood Illnesses
    Childhood neglect and abuse
    Childhood Obesity
    Chitosan
    Chocolate (cocoa)
    Cholesterol
    Cholesterol drugs
    Cholesterol Hypothesis Skeptics
    Cholesterol Myths
    Cholesterol, HDL
    Chromium
    Chronic Fatigue
    Citrus aurantium
    CLA (Conjugated Linoleic Acid)
    Clozaril (clozapine)
    Cobalt
    Cochrane Collaboration
    Codonopsis Eupolyphaga
    Coffee
    Coffee, Decaffeinated
    Cognitive function
    Commercial Weight Loss Programs
    Computer Use
    Conflicts of Interest
    Congestive Heart Failure
    Constipation
    Contrave (Wellbutrin (bupropion) plus naltrexone)
    Copper
    CoQ10 (Coenzyme Q10, ubiquinol, ubiquinone)
    Cortisol (stress hormone)
    Cost of food
    Costs associated with obesity
    Cravings
    Cymbalta (duloxetine)
    Daniel Amen, MD
    Death, Risk of
    Deaths from obesity
    Definitions
    Dementia (see Alzheimer's also)
    Dental Amalgams (mercury fillings)
    Depo-Provera (depot-medroxyprogesterone acetate)
    Depression
    Desire to Lose Weight
    DHEA
    Diabetes
    Diabetes drugs
    Diagnosed Overweight by a Doctor
    Dialysis
    Diet drug use
    Diet Pills (General Info)
    Diet soda
    Dietary Counseling
    Diethylpropion (Tenuate)
    Dieting (General)
    Dieting, Intermittent
    Dinitrophenol
    Disability
    Discrimination against obesity
    Diuretics
    Diverticulitis
    Doctor - Abram Hoffer, MD, PhD
    Doctor - Boyd Haley, PhD
    Doctor - Dr. Kailash Chand
    Doctor - H. Gilbert Welch, MD (author of Overdiagnosed and Less Medicine, More Health)
    Doctor - Irving Kirsch, PhD
    Doctor - Jason Fung, MD
    Doctor - Joel Kauffman, PhD (author of Malignant Medical Myths)
    Doctor - John Abramson, MD (author of Overdosed America)
    Doctor - Jonathan Wright, MD (pioneer in natural medicine)
    Doctor - Kimber Stanhope, PhD
    Doctor - Malcolm Kendrick, MD author of "The Great Cholesterol Con"
    Doctor - Marcia Angell, MD
    Doctor - Mary Enig, PhD
    Doctor - Michel de Lorgeril, MD
    Doctor - Peter Gøtzsche, MD
    Doctor - Robert Lustig, MD
    Doctor - Steven Gundry, MD
    Doctor - Suzanne Humphries, MD
    Doctor - Uffe Ravnskov, MD PhD
    Doctor - William Wilson, MD
    Doctor trends
    Don't fall for this
    Dopamine agonists
    Drug company lies
    Drug Company Money
    Drug Company Salesman
    Drug Company Tactics
    Drug-induced Side Effects
    Dry Skin
    Duodenal Switch (weight loss surgery)
    Eating time of day
    Economic Issues and Obesity
    Education
    Eggs
    Elavil (amitriptyline)
    Elderly
    Elderly, risk of obesity
    Electrolyte abnormalities (magnesium, potassium, sodium, calcium, phosphate)
    Empatic (Zonegran plus Wellbutrin)
    Environmental chemicals
    Ephedrine/Ephedra
    Epigenetics
    Erectile Dysfunction
    Escitalopram (Lexapro)
    Estrogen replacement therapy
    Evening Primrose Oil
    Every Other Day Modified Fast
    Excalia
    Exercise
    Exhaustion
    Fast Food
    Fasting, Intermittent
    Fat Cells
    Fat Intake (Dietary Fat)
    Fat loss
    Fat Oxidation
    Fat Replacers
    Fat, Body (Body Fat)
    Fat, Dietary
    FDA (U.S. Food and Drug Administration)
    Fen-Phen
    Fertility (see Pregnancy)
    Fiber (Dietary Fiber)
    Fiber supplements
    Fidgeting
    Fish
    Fish Oil (omega-3 fatty acids)
    Flaxseed
    Food Allergies (See Allergies, Food and Brain)
    Food Cues
    Food Diary
    Food Intake statistics
    Food preferences associated with obesity
    Food Pyramid
    Food Safety
    Food's effect on appetite
    Foods associated with higher and lower body weight
    Foods Associated with Weight Gain
    Forskolin (from the plant Coleus forskohlii)
    Fosamax (alendronate)
    Fructose
    Fruit
    Fucoxanthin
    GABA
    Gallbadder Disease
    Gallstones
    Garlic
    Gastro-esophageal reflux disease
    General Health Checks
    Genes and genetics
    Geodon (ziprasidone)
    Ghrelin
    Ginger
    Ginseng
    GLA (Gamma Linolenic Acid)
    GLA - Gamma Linolenic Acid
    Glucomannan (konjac root)
    Glucophage (metformin)
    Glutamine (amino acid)
    Glycemic Index
    Glycemic Index Tables
    Glycomacropeptide
    GMO foods (genetically modified organisms)
    Grains
    Grapefruit
    Green coffee bean extract
    Green Tea
    Group Therapy
    Growth Hormone
    Guar gum
    Gut Bacteria
    Gwen Olsen
    Habits associated with obesity
    Habits of being lean
    Hair Loss (caused by weight loss)
    Haldol (haloperidol)
    Hawaiian Diet
    HCG (human chorionic gonadotropin)
    Headaches
    Health Insurance
    Health Risks of obesity
    Heart Attack (myocardial infarction)
    Heart Disease
    Heart Disease, Coronary - Skeptics of the Cholesterol Hypothesis
    Heavy metal toxicity
    Herbal formula, Number Ten
    Herbal formula, PM-F2-OB
    Hibiscus tea
    High Carbohydrate Diet
    High-Fructose Corn Syrup
    High-Protein / Low-Carb Diets
    Histamine levels
    History
    Holiday Weight Gain
    Homocysteine
    Hoodia
    Hop extract, isomerized
    Hunger
    Hydralazine
    Hydrogenated vegetable oil (partially hydrogenated oil)
    Hydroxycitrate (HCA)
    Hypoglycemia
    Hypothyroidism, including Type 2 Hypothyroidism
    IGF-1 (insulin-like growth factor-1)
    Income level
    Infections
    Infertility
    Influenza (Flu)
    Injuries
    Insulin
    Insulin sensitivity
    Interview with Patients
    Interview with Stephen Gullo, PhD
    Interviews with Doctors
    Iodine
    Jenny Craig Weight Loss Program
    Joan Mathews Larson, PhD
    John Ioannidis
    Just for Fun
    Kidney Disease
    Kidney Injury, Acute
    Kidney Stones
    Kidney stones
    Konjac root (See glucomannan)
    Krill Oil
    Lap Band Surgery
    Lead (heavy metal toxicity)
    Lean, things associated with being
    Legumes
    Leptin
    Lesbians
    Leucine (amino acid)
    Life Expectancy
    Lipolysis (release of fat from fat cells)
    Liposuction
    Lipozene (see glucomannan)
    Liquid Calories
    Liraglutide
    Longevity
    Lorcaserin (also see Belviq (lorcaserin hydrochloride))
    Low Calorie Diet
    Low Carbohydrate Diets
    Low Fat Diets
    Low Stomach Acid
    Lp(a)
    Ludiomil (maprotiline)
    Luvox (fluvoxamine)
    Magnesium
    Maitake mushroom
    Mammography
    Marijuana (see Cannabis)
    Mark Starr, MD
    Married or Single
    Meal Frequency
    Meal Replacement Shakes
    Measurments of obesity
    Meat, Red
    Mediterranean Diet
    Medium chain triglycerides (MCT's)
    Men, studies about
    Menopause
    Menstruation
    Mercury
    Mercury fillings (Dental amalgams)
    Meridia (sibutramine)
    Metabolic syndrome (also see Insulin Sensitivity)
    Metabolism
    Mifeprex (mifepristone)
    Milk and Dairy
    Mineral aspartates
    Mirapex (pramipexole)
    Mirtazapine (antidepressant Remeron)
    Moban (molindone)
    Monounsaturated fat (Olive Oil and Canola Oil)
    Mortality associated with obesity
    Motivational techniques for losing weight
    Movies
    MSG (monosodium glutamate)
    Multiple Myeloma (See Cancer, Multiple Myeloma)
    Myths, Medical Myths
    N-Acetyl-Cysteine (NAC)
    Naltrexone
    Nasal Blockage
    Nassim Taleb
    Natural Treatments
    Nestatin-1
    Neurontin (gabapentin)
    Niacin (vitamin B3)
    Nicotine
    Night Eating Syndrome
    Night workers/shift workers
    No Dinner Diet
    Nonalcoholic fatty liver disease
    Nortriptyline (See Pamelor)
    Nutrasweet (aspartame)
    Nuts (also see Almonds)
    Obesity Forecasts
    Obesity Guidelines, NIH
    Obesity statistics
    Obesity Statistics, US States
    Obesity, Causes of
    Obesity, Factors associated with
    Oleoyl-estrone
    Olestra
    Olive Oil
    Omega-3 Fatty Acids (fish oil)
    Omega-6 Fatty Acids
    Onions
    Oolong Tea
    Opinion
    Orthomolecular Medicine
    Over-treatment
    Paleo Diet
    Pamelor (nortriptyline)
    Parent's influence on obesity
    Parkinson's Disease
    Paroxetine (antidepressant Paxil)
    PCSK9 inhibitors (cholesterol-lowering drugs)
    Pedometer
    Periactin (cyproheptadine)
    Periodontal Gum Disease
    Personal stories about weigh loss
    Phen-Pro (Phentermine-Prozac or other SSRIs)
    Phendimetrazine (Bontril)
    Phentermine
    Phenylephrine
    Phosphodiesterase type-5 inhibitors, sildenafil (Viagra), tadalafil (Cialis), vardenafil (Levitra)
    Plastic's effect on body weight
    Plate Size
    Pokeweed extract
    Polar Weight Management Program
    Polio Vaccine (Salk Vaccine)
    Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome
    Polyunsaturated Fat
    Port, Sidney (UCLA statistician)
    Portion size, effect on calore intake
    Post-traumatic stress disorder
    Postnatal weight gain (immediately after birth)
    Postpartum depression
    Potassium
    Pramlintide (see Symlin)
    Predicted Weight Loss
    Pregnancy
    Pregnant women, effects on offspring
    Prejudice against obesity
    Prevalence of Obesity
    Prices for drugs
    Prolixin (fluphenazine)
    Prostate, Enlarged
    Protamine
    Protein (general)
    Protein from meat
    Protein from nuts & seeds
    Protein from plants
    Protein Leverage Theory
    Protein Source
    Protein supplement
    Protein, High, Diet
    Protein, Low, Diet
    Protein, Soy
    Proton pump inhibitors
    Proton Pump Inhibitors (PPI's)
    Prozac (fluoxetine)
    PSA Test (Prostate Specific Antigen)
    Psychiatric Drugs
    Pu-erh Tea (Chinese Black Tea)
    Pursuing Weight Control
    Pyruvate
    Qsymia (phentermine and topiramate) (formerly Qnexa)
    Quality of Life
    Quercetin
    Radiation (background ionizing radiation)
    Rate of Eating
    Raw food diet
    Red Yeast Rice
    Resistant Starch
    Resveratrol
    Rhodiola rosea (Golden root or Arctic root)
    Rice
    Richard Moore, MD, PhD
    Risperdal (risperidone)
    Ritalin (methylphenidate)
    Robert Skversky, MD
    Robert Whitaker (author & journalist)
    Rubidium
    Saccharin (artificial sweetner)
    Saturated Fat
    Sauna
    Scams
    Schizophrenia
    Seizures
    Self-help weight loss
    Self-reported height and weight
    Self-reported intake
    Serentil (mesoridazine)
    Serlect (sertindole)
    Seroquel (quetiapine)
    Serotonin Syndrome
    Serzone (nefazodone)
    Sex and Sexual Activity
    Sexual abuse
    Shift Workers
    Sick Days
    Simmondsin (jojoba plant seed extract)
    Skinny on Obesity video series
    Sleep
    Sleeping pills
    Smoking's effect on weight
    Snacks
    Snoring
    Social Influence
    Sodium Intake
    Soft drinks (Coke, Pepsi, etc.)
    South Beach Diet
    Splenda (sucralose)
    Spouses
    SSRI's
    Starch Blockers (Amylase inhibitors)
    Statin Nation (documentary)
    Statins
    Stearic Acid (in beef and chocolate)
    Stents (coronary artery stents)
    Strattera (atomoxetine)
    Strength Training
    Stress
    Stroke, hemorrhagic
    Stroke, ischemic
    Sugar Addiction
    Sugar intake
    Suicide
    Sumatriptan
    Sun Bathing, Benefits of
    Surmontil (trimipramine)
    Symlin (pramlintide)
    Symlin (pramlintide)
    Sympathetic Nervous Activity (SNS)
    Taranabant
    Taste
    Taubes, Gary
    Taxes and Obesity
    Tea
    Television Watching
    Temperature, House
    Tenuate (See diethylpropion)
    Tesofensine
    Testosterone
    Thermogenesis
    Thermography
    Thiomersal (mercury-containing preservative)
    Thorazine (chlorpromazine)
    Thyroid Function
    Thyroid supplement
    Thyroid, Desiccated
    Timeline related to obesity discoveries
    Tofranil (imipramine)
    Tofu (soybean curd)
    Tonsils
    Too much medicine
    Topamax (topiramate)
    TOPS (Take Off Pounds Sensibly)
    Trans Fats
    Trazedone (antidepressant)
    Tricyclic antidepressants
    Triglyceride levels
    Tryptophan
    Underreporting weight
    Urinary incontinence
    Vaccines
    Vegetable-based Diet
    Vegetables
    Vegetables, Raw
    Vegetarians
    Venlafaxine (antidepressant Effexor)
    Ventricular arrhythmias
    Vertical Banded Gastroplasty
    Very-Low-Calorie Diets
    Vibration, Whole Body
    Vinegar
    Virus and Bacteria associated with obesity
    Virus, obesity (adenovirus-36)
    Visual Cues
    Vitamin C
    Vitamin D
    Vitamins
    Waist measurement
    Waist-to-Hip Ratio
    Wansink, Brian (studies done by)
    Water
    Weighing, Self
    Weight cycling (gaining and losing)
    Weight gain
    Weight Lifting
    Weight Loss Expectations
    Weight Loss Programs
    Weight Loss Strategies
    Weight Loss Success (what successful weight losers do)
    Weight Loss Supplements
    Weight Loss Supplements, Adulterated
    Weight loss surgery
    Weight Loss Surgery - Laparoscopic Sleeve Gastrectomy
    Weight Loss, Benefits of
    Weight loss, Rate of
    Weight loss, risks of
    Weight Maintenance
    Weight monitoring
    Weight Perception
    Weight Watchers
    Weight-gaining drugs
    Wellbutrin (bupropion)
    Wine, Red
    Women, studies about
    Work, Lost Days
    Xenical (orlistat)
    YouTube videos
    Zerona laser
    Zetia (ezetimibe)
    Zinc
    Zocor (simvastatin)
    Zoloft (sertraline)
    Zonegran (zonisamide)
    Zyprexa (olanzapine)

    ARCHIVES

    July, 2019
    June, 2019
    May, 2019
    April, 2019
    March, 2019
    January, 2019
    December, 2018
    October, 2018
    September, 2018
    August, 2018
    July, 2018
    June, 2018

    ARCHIVE SUMMARY

    View by Date
    View by Category

    RSS / XML


    RSS 1.0
    RSS 2.0
    RSS Atom

    WEATHER

    Weather around the country
    Home page  >  Article | Previous article | Next article

    QUICKLINKS AND VIEW OPITONS

  • Articles with Recent Comments
  • Recent Forum Topics
  • Summary View
  • Headline View
  • Archive of Quotes
  • Follow @fatnews

    Low-carb diet causes nearly twice as much weight loss as low-fat: 26 lbs vs 14 lbs


    Posted by .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)
    Monday, October 25, 2010 9:27 am Email this article
    Patients eating a low-carbohydrate group lost nearly twice as much weight as those in the low-fat group. Those in the low-carb group lost an average of 26.4 pounds versus 14.3 pounds for those in the low-fat group. Weight Loss

    Weight Loss: 12.9% VS 6.7%

    As a percent of starting weight this represented 12.9 percent for the low-carbohydrate group and 6.7 percent for the low-fat group.

    It is important to point out that the calorie intake of the low-carbohydrate group was not restricted, whereas the calorie intake of the low-fat group was. As is noted below, both groups ate roughly 1500 calories per day, however, the low-carbohydrate group lost nearly twice as much weight.

    One possible explanation for this is that a high-protein increases metabolism according to the authors. (p. 775, col. 2)

     

    Weight Loss Compared to Diet Pills Xenical and Meridia

    Low-Carb Weight Loss Greater Than With Xenical Or Meridia: 13% Vs 9% Vs 8%

    The average weight loss in low-carbohydrate group was greater than the average weight loss seen with Xenical (orlistat) which causes an average weight loss of about 9 percent after six months according to the authors of the study, and greater than the average weight loss seen with Meridia (sibutramine) which causes an average weight loss of about 8 percent after six months according to the authors of the study. (p. 775, col. 1)

     

    10% Weight Loss or More

    How Many Lost At Least 10 Percent: 61% Vs 23%

    Nearly three times as many patients in the low-carbohydrate group lost at least 10 percent of their body weight as those in the low-fat group: 61 percent of of the group versus 23 percent.

     

    Fat Loss

    Fat Loss: 20.7 Lbs Vs 10.6 Lbs

    Patients in the low-carbohydrate group lost nearly twice as much body fat as those in the low-fat group: 20.7 pounds versus 10.6 pounds.

    Average percent body fat decreased from 41 percent to 35 percent in the low-carbohydrate group compared to from 41 percent to 38 percent in the low-fat group.

     

    Muscle Loss

    Muscle Loss: 20.7 Lbs Vs 10.6 Lbs

    Patients in the low-carbohydrate group lost slightly more lean body mass than those in the low-fat group: 7.3 pounds versus 5.3 pounds. This is the result of losing more body weight.

     

    Triglycerides

    Triglycerides: -74 Mg Per Deciliter Vs -28 Mg Per Deciliter

    There was a greater decrease in triglycerides levels in the low-carbohydrate group than those in the low-fat group: -74 mg per deciliter vs -28 mg per deciliter.

     

    HDL

    HDL: +6 Mg Per Deciliter Vs -2 Mg Per Deciliter

    There was an increase in HDL cholesterol levels in the low-carbohydrate group ??? which is associated with a decrease in the risk of heart disease ??? whereas there was a slight decrease in the low-fat group: +6 mg per deciliter vs -2 mg per deciliter.

    HDL went from 55 to 61 mg/dL in the low-carb group, and 54 to 52 mg/dL in the low-fat group.

    It should be noted that HDL levels usually drop when a person is losing weight and then increases when a person???s weight stabilizes. The increase in HDL levels seen in low-carb group is known to occur when carbohydrates are replaced by saturated, monounsaturated, or polyunsaturated fat according to the authors. (p. 775, col. 2)

     

    LDL

    LDL: +2 Mg Per Deciliter Vs -7 Mg Per Deciliter

    Levels of LDL cholesterol increased by 2 mg/dL in the low-carbohydrate group ??? which is associated with a increase in the risk of heart disease ??? whereas there was a decrease in the low-fat group of 7 mg per deciliter.

    LDL levels increased by more than 10 percent in one-third (30 percent) of people in the low-carb group. (p. 775, col. 2)

    The authors note that in an uncontrolled trial of twenty-four people on the low-carb diet, LDL levels increased by 24 mg/dL after two months.

    Hoever, another low-carb study that involved forty-one pople found that LDL levels decreased by 10 mg/dL after six months.

    Blood lipids should be monitored for anyone on a low-carb diet since it may increase LDL according to the authors of the study. (p. 775, col. 2)

     

    Systolic Blood Pressure

    Systolic Blood Pressure: -10 mmHg VS -8 mmHg

    Systolic blood pressure decreased by 10 mmHg low-carbohydrate group compared to 8 mmHg in the low-fat group.

     

    Diastolic Blood Pressure

    Diastolic Blood Pressure: -6 mmHg VS -5 mmHg

    Diastolic blood pressure decreased by 6 mmHg low-carbohydrate group compared to 5 mmHg in the low-fat group.

     

    Pulse Rate

    Pulse Rate: -9 Beats Per Minute Vs -10 Beats Per Minute

    Pulse rate decreased by 9 beats per minute in the low-carbohydrate group compared to 10 beats per minute in the low-fat group.

     

    Insulin Sensitivity

    Insulin Sensitivity: Previous Studies Show Low-Carb Increases Sensitivity

    Insulin sensitivity was not measured in this study, but previous studies have found that low-carb diets lower blood sugar and insulin levels according to the authors. (p. 776, col. 1)

     

    Low-Carb in Metabolic Syndrome

    Low-Carb Diet May Be Warranted In People With Metabolic Syndrome

    The positive changes in body weight, blood pressure, and serum lipids suggest that a low-carb diet may be beneficial for people with metabolic syndrome, also known as Syndrome X, which is characterized by excess belly fat, insulin resistance, increased blood pressure, elevated triglycerides, and low HDL levels.

     

    Adverse Effects

    Adverse Effects

    Adverse effects were more common in the low-carb group than the low-fat group.

    Constipation occurred in 68 percent of patient in the low-carb group versus 35 percent of patients in the low-fat group. One patient in the low-carb group sought medical attention for constipation.

    Headaches occurred in 60 percent of patient in the low-carb group versus 40 percent of patients in the low-fat group.

    Bad breath occurred in 38 percent of patient in the low-carb group versus 8 percent of patients in the low-fat group.

    Muscle cramps occurred in 35 percent of patient in the low-carb group versus 7 percent of patients in the low-fat group.

    Diarrhea occurred in 23 percent of patient in the low-carb group versus 7 percent of patients in the low-fat group.

    General weakness occurred in 25 percent of patient in the low-carb group versus 8 percent of patients in the low-fat group.

    Rash occurred in 13 percent of patient in the low-carb group versus 0 percent of patients in the low-fat group.

    Adverse Effects: Low-Carb Diet May Increase The Risk

    A recent study found that a 2,000 calorie low-carb diet may increase the risk of kidney stones according to the authors of the study. (p. 776, col. 2)

    They noted that the nutritional supplements included citric acid, which may have helped prevent formation of kidney stones according to the authors. (p. 776, col. 2)

     

    Serious Adverse Effects

    Serious Adverse Effects

    A 53-year-old man in the low-carbohydrate group developed chest pain near the end of the study, and was subsequently diagnosed with coronary heart disease. He had a family history of early heart disease. During the study he had lost 35.2 pounds, his LDL cholesterol had dropped by 29 mg/dL and his HDL cholesterol had increased by 8 mg/dL.

     

    Dropouts

    Droupouts: 3 In The Low-Carb Group

    Three people the low-carbohydrate group dropped out of the study because of adverse effects. Two had increases in LDL cholesterol, and one experienced shakiness and uneasiness.

     

    Finishing the Study

    More In The Low-Carb Group Finished The Study: 76% Vs 57%

    More people in the low-carbohydrate group than in the low-fat group completed the six month study: 76 percent versus 57 percent.

     

    Low-Carb Diet

    The Low-Carb Diet: Less Than 20 Grams Per Day

    The low-carbohydrate diet consisted of limiting carbohydrate intake to less than 20 grams per day, took nutritional supplements, were recommended to exercise and had group meetings.

    The nutritional supplements included fish oil, which has been shown to decrease triglycerides and slightly increase levels of LDL and HDL according to the authors. (p. 776, col. 1)

    An analysis of what they ate found that they actually consumed an average of 30 grams of carbohydrates per day or 8 percent of calories, 98 grams of protein or 26 pecent of calories, and 111 grams of fat or 68 percent of daily calories.

     

    Low-Fat Diet

    The Low-Fat Diet: Less Than 30% Of Calories From Fat

    The low-fat diet was designed to be 500 to 1,000 calories per day less than a person???s needs, less than 30 percent of calories from fat, less than 300 mg of cholesterol per day, plus a recommendation to exercise and group meetings.

    They also took nutritional supplements, were recommended to exercise and had group meetings.

    An analysis of what they ate found that the low-fat group consumed an average of 198 grams of carbohydrates per day or 52 percent of calories, 71 grams of protein or 19 pecent of calories, and 49 grams of fat or 29 percent of daily calories.

     

    Calorie Intake

    Calorie Intake: 1500 Calories In Both Groups

    An analysis of self-reported intakes estimated calorie intake to be an average of 1461 calories per day in the low-carbohydrate group, and 1502 calories in the low-fat group.

    It is important to remember that the calorie intake of the low-carbohydrate group was not restricted. In other words, this type of diet spontaneously caused a reduction in calorie intake without any specific instructions to do so.

     

    Subjects

    Subjects

    One-hundred twenty people started the study. They were 18- to 65-years-old with a body mass index of 30 to 60 (obese to extremely obese) with a total cholesterol level of 200 mg/dL or more, LDL levels of 130 mg/dL or more, or triglycerides of 200 mg/dL or more, and no serious medical conditions.

     

    Criteria: No Diet Pills Recently

    No Diet Pills In The Previous Six Months, Other Medications In The Previous Two Months

    Patients were excluded if they had taken any prescription weight loss medicine in the previous six months or any other prescription medication in the previous two months except for birth control pills, estrogen therapy or stable thyroid medication.

     

    Study Support

    Study Supported By The Atkins Foundation

    The study was supported by a grant from the Robert C. Atkins Foundation.

    REFERENCE

    Yancy WJ, Olsen M, Guyton J, Bakst R, Westman E. A low-carbohydrate, ketogenic diet versus a low-fat diet to treat obesity and hyperlipidemia: a randomized, controlled trial. Ann Intern Med. 2004 May 18, 140(10):769-77.

    HOW TO GET A COPY OF THE STUDY

    This study can be downloaded from:

    http://www.annals.org/cgi/reprint/140/10/769.pdf

    Single copies of this study may also be requested from one of the authors of the study:

    Eric C. Westman, MD, MHS
    Duke University Medical Center
    Box 50, Suite 200-B Wing
    2200 West Main Street, Durham, NC 27705
    .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)

    Articles on the same subject can be found here:


    COMMENTS

    On Feb 25, 2005 at 10:31 am Jon Peterson wrote:

    . . . . .

    I work as a personal trainer for an adolescent boarding school designed to help teenagers lose weight. We use a low fat diet and see tremendous results, results that far surpass these low carb numbers, without the adverse side effects. (In a 6 month time period we have seen up to 30% decrease in total body weight, and as much as 155 lbs lost) The key is to define what a low fat diet truly is, and in our case, that is 7-15 grams of fat per day with a calorie intake similar to the patients listed here. In this study, patients were eating 30% of their calories from fat! For the average person eating what they monitor to be 1500 calories, we are looking at 50 grams of fat per day! Human error in self monitoring calorie intake is highly likely, as most people greatly underestimate this aspect of weight loss, and those fat intake numbers could be pushing 70 grams per day with a 2000 calorie diet. This study is highly flawed in comparing low fat to low carb. Low carb diets will work better than a diet containing 50 plus grams of fat per day, but cannot compare to a true low fat nutritional plan.

    -Jon Peterson

    Please feel free to share your comments about this article.


    Name:

    Email:

    Comments:

    Please enter the word you see in the image below:


    Remember my personal information

    Notify me of follow-up comments?



    © Copyright 2003-2017 - Larry Hobbs - All Rights Reserved.